European Union Considers Green Import Taxes


Co2 emissionsThe European Union is currently considering proposals to levy import taxes on goods from countries that do not sign up to emissions treaties.

Taxes will likely be charged based on the equivalent price of an EU emissions permit for specific goods as a way of levelling the playing field between goods manufactured subject to emissions cap & trade regulations and goods from nations not imposing restrictions.

We are not completely sure that this is a workable idea.. Whilst easing some of the short term fears that business leaders within the EU have regarding competition from ‘dirty’ imports, the scheme is likely to achieve little else. We cannot imagine nations implementing emissions trading purely in response to the threat of import tariffs, and firms that rely on foreign imports will be hit. Meanwhile, import tariffs which are applicable in one region only are unlikely to encourage dirty industries to clean up their act.

The real objective of encouraging global competition in the development of green technologies will only be achieved when all industrial nations fully sign up to a global scheme. With the political process inching towards a conclusion following the moderate success at Bali in December it would make more sense to wait for the real deal, rather than implement messy trade tariff schemes. No doubt some of readers may have even stronger views?

Watch out for our piece on the Pro’s & Con’s of emissions cap & trade schemes later this week.

Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.


Other Posts
50 People Who Could Save the Planet - but Won’t
Climate Change Nonsense of the Week

Tags


Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

Reader Comments

Read my Predictions for 2008!
My Predictions for 2008

This is one of them.

Insightful predictions, but to what extent do you believe that each of them are based on climate change issues as a root cause?

About half, the other half are general global factors, yet they will affect climate realted economic decisions going forward.
The primary reason that environment is on everyone’s mind is because the economy has not started to decline, but the warning signs are there, nothing like some unemployment and hardship to change the focus of a population.
I would be happy to make some climate specific predictions, I am just really centered on the economics right now.

I have added some climate specific predictions for you Mark. Plus some political and technological ones directly as a result of mitigation research.

I did not have anything too amazing climate change wise, the year will be pretty quiet on that front.

Thanks for that. It’s good to see people willing to commit themselves. I’m curious to watch these through the year!

Thanks for this.

From Bali, the impression was that less developed countries would not need to impose restrictions yet, which sounded good on the surface. Not long after it turns out that we are considering imposing the restrictions in other ways. No doubt we will then lend them money so that they can buy the allowances from us, exacerbating their debt.

Nothing ever changes… I’d like to hear some Greens coming forward to justify this action being taken on their behalf.

Nice predictions CH, I’m looking forward to Gore getting mad at the UN conference! ;)

Ok, as a green I’ll bite. I don’t think the intention is to penalize poor countries, just ones that do not sign-up to emissions reductions and may potentially profit from selling cheaper goods as a result. The US and China being prime examples.

As the post says - “Level the playing field”.

Phil,

The EU applying trade tariffs to any country is the application of economic force to have others submit to your political viewpoint. It is one step away from economic sanctions.
It has nothing to do with a level playing field unless the green camp finally agrees that the economic costs of mitigation are extreme.
It is my understanding that the green team believes that the new “green” economy will be stronger than the old and moves to alternative energy will have positive economic benefits. This should make emission reduced countries or unions much better competitively as they will have stronger economies.

See the Stern Report.

Prediction Update:

Jan 10th, 2007

Ontario and Quebec announce plans for a study into a high speed rail system starting in Eastern Canada to help combat climate change.

This was the first stop in the North American Rail Grid to be proposed that I predicted.

[…] that many industries may be tempted to relocate, the EU are considering imposing import taxes on certain goods from nations which do not impose similar carbon restrictions. “What we […]

Compare the IMF 2008 predictions just released to my economic predictions for 2008.

Pretty Close.

IMF 2008 Growth