Reflections on 2007 and expectations for 2008


2007 to 2008

2007 was a big year in Climate Change, which saw the US u-turn on climate policy (on the surface at least), the emergence of the EU and the UK as world climate leaders, continued climate record breaking as temperatures soared and the North West passage was opened up, the worldwide release of An Inconvenient Truth, the award of the Nobel Prize to Al Gore and the IPCC, the Bali Summit meeting, and last but not least, the further emergence of some very serious and hard to ignore questions from climate sceptics and the growing body of evidence suggesting that climate change might not be man-made after all.

What did I learn from 2007, and what do we need for 2008?

TalkClimateChange has always believed 4 things:

  1. That the climate is certainly changing - irrespective of the cause
  2. That there is some credible science to suggest mankind’s greatest achievement (the industrial revolution) is the cause of this
  3. That there is some credible science that suggests exactly the opposite
  4. That all of our lives will change as a result of the ensuing political and social and economic mayhem as the world comes to realise how big a deal a changing climate might be for us
  5. That it is usually better to prepare for change rather than just wait for it to happen

(more on our climate change beliefs)

With these points in mind - and considering the increased attention and focus that climate change received during 2007 - what were my personal climate conscience related experiences during the past year?

I used commercial air transportation more than ever before

(minus 5 good climate citizen points)

Unfortunately my personal circumstances demanded this, which tells me that arguments to limit air travel are wrong. People need to travel for many different practical reasons, more and more so as our worlds become global. I believe that preventing climate change shouldn’t (and doesn’t have to) come at the expense of world development. Globalization is a good thing - it is generating the wealth to fight poverty and inequality - and with a global environment comes the need for global travel. (more thoughts on climate change and aviation)

I failed to fix the thermostats in my apartment which make it a permanently too warm

(minus 5 good climate citizen points)

No excuses on this one, other than laziness and the fact that the first repairman failed to bring any replacement thermostats with him after being asked to “come and replace the thermostats”. I guess I could always figure out how to do this myself however. I’ll most probably learn when the heating bill arrives.

I failed to turn my apartment into a CFL, tastefully lit and low energy environment

(minus 5 good climate citizen points)

Despite encouraging news of advanced low energy LED lighting and advances in CFLs (compact fluorescent light bulbs) which allow use with dimmer switches, most of my apartment is lit with incandescent or halogen bulbs.

Why? Because despite the hype, the low energy wonder bulbs are just not easily available. I can’t find bulbs with more than an equivalent of 120 watts output, and I can’t find any that will work with dimmer switches. Admittedly I haven’t looked very far, but the world won’t go green if everybody has to drive to the next city to buy simple green commodities.

I took two long haul holidays

(minus 10 good climate citizen points)

No excuse. I needed a break. Twice. However, it was during the first holiday that I came up with the idea of TalkClimateChange, and during the second that I decided not to shut it down again.

I didn’t get into Audio or e-Books

(minus 5 good climate citizen points)

Audio and e-Books were recently hailed as a great green invention with the potential to save the millions of trees required to carry the printed word by conventional means. I remember that the ‘electronic office’ was supposed to do the same thing. (see more thoughts on whether the internet is really a green technology). I did however convert my entire music collection to MP3 and no longer use or buy CD’s. Admittedly this was driven purely by convenience and will have an absolutely minimal effect on Co2 emissions..

I continued to walk to work every day instead of driving

(plus 5 good climate citizen points)

This one was an easy win; since I am one of the few fortunate (or unfortunate) enough to live close to where I work. If I lived further away then the reality (for me and 90% of the population) is that I would take the most convenient method of transport, which (also for 90% of the population) is the car.

So I have a net ‘good climate citizen’ score of minus 25 points. What will this mean for 2008?

What will this mean for 2008?

The easy thing would be to believe that point 3 above is true (that there is credible evidence suggesting that climate change is notmanmade) instead of point 2 (that climate change is manmade). But this would be too easy. And it is much more fun to play both beliefs against each other.

What this really means for 2008 is that it is still too hard for many people to make sensible green choices. For all of the government rhetoric about fighting climate change, and for all of the good work carried out by campaigners, climate change prevention still hasn’t become mainstream - meaning that ordinary people don’t have easy access to green options: Some examples based on my 2007 experiences;

Air travel - It is essential for many people. But, for example, the UK government has increased aviation tax as a token disincentive which hasn’t stopped people flying, but just made people feel more pain. How about putting that extra tax into offset schemes instead? Or better still - providing properly regulated offset schemes, or demanding that airlines make offsetting easy and transparent? Or improving antiquated air traffic control systems which waste fuel through inefficient air traffic management?

Low energy light bulbs - why is it so difficult to find low energy alternatives for all uses other than the light in the broom cupboard? I live in a major city so I don’t understand why these things are so hard to find.

Transportation - options for public transportation in most areas are simply woeful. People will never give up the car whilst public transport is just so bad. Some countries have made public transport stress free, cheap and efficient to the point that taking the car is a nuisance. Why do so many others turn the use of public transport into some kind of masochism?

One can always make an effort, as I could. But my point is that very few people will go too far out of their way.

So, New Year’s resolutions for 2008 - make more effort to lead a more sustainable lifestyle, preferably aiming for a ‘good climate citizen’ score of 0 or higher.

New Year’s wishes - that after all the very positive statements of 2007, some positive and sensible and achievable initiatives take place to make the green world easy to live in.

What are your new year’s reflections, resolutions and wishes? Leave a comment and let us know.

Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.


Other Posts
Do green campaigners need a new strategy?
Happy 2008!

Tags


Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word

Reader Comments

Mark,
Great, honest and very insightful article. It made me think of something I wrote a while ago, about Pascal’s wager argument:
http://lamarguerite.wordpress.com/2007/11/16/disarming-the-climate-change-skeptics-with-pascals-wager-argument/

Happy New Year to you, and best wishes for your blog. I am adding it to my blogroll by the way.

marguerite

Happy New Year to all Teams!

Mark it seems you and I lead parallel lives. I too took 2 long haul vacations (Canada to Europe) + 1 Cruise to Mexico. I flew once a month, each trip over 2,500km each way, for work. I started my website/personal blog as well.

I bought CFLs, but with a good/bad rate of 50% (First six pack all the bulbs were broken, second pack 3 did not work). Then I found out about the mercury, and that I had no safe way to dispose of them so I stopped buying them. So, not to be a deterred, I installed some traditional tube flourescent lights in my home office and kitchen ( this is because the lights are on in these rooms almost constantly and I got tired of changing bulbs). I bought an AC unit, which was energy star and used less power than the fans I has before.

I ride mass transit everyday for 80% of my needs, I walk obviously much more as a result. My car battery keeps dying because I drive so little these days. I car pool for shopping with my sister who lives 10 minutes from me.

I also live in a province with almost no CO2 emissions from electrical power generation. Yet I conserve and my power use (including my “always on” computers (5) and AV/Game center and my home office, which is my primary workplace as I closed my downtown office to save the expense), is about 400Kwh/month ( about half of most homes in Canada ) on average.

Yet I do not believe that the current climate is unusual, nor it it a harbinger of catastrophe.

I learned this year so much more than I thought possible about climate science, the state of the scientific community, global politics, human psychology and the UN.

My New Years resolution is to keep up with the science, but concentrate on the economics, and keep the debate going anywhere I can, like here on this excellent site.

Thanks for the comments and the New Year wishes from you both. - Helps to fight off this flu and get started with a new year of TalkClimateChanging!

Mark, I have to agree with you that green options are not as accessible as they should be. Plus, they can be expensive.

Take recycling for instance. Just trying to recycle a CFL is not easy without expending an effort. Most people are just not going to take the time. So,what happens? They throw them in the trash, mercury and all. Although I believe using CFLs are better than not despite the mercury issue, the businesses who sell them could step up to the plate as well.

However, my view is everything you do better like walking, which you mentioned, is just one more thing to help the Earth. My motto is try the best you can. As you continue to green your life, it will become habit and not change. Sometimes you have to crawl before you can walk.

Happy new years and may it bring lots of growth for Talk Climate Change.

Nice post as always, Mark. anna http://www.green-talk.com